Fourth International Documents

Conferences, congresses and resolutions, in English

The Third World Congress and the split 1950-1952 › The crisis and split in the French PCI (1951–1952)

Letter from Ernest Germain to the Bleibtreu-Lambert Tendency

The crisis and split in the French PCI (1951–1952) · 1,792 words

Building the International

Published English text: Towards a History of the Fourth International, Part 4, vol. 2: Struggle in the Fourth International — International Secretariat Documents 1951-1954, Volume 2 of 4 volumes (Education for Socialists, Socialist Workers Party, New York, March 1974), pp. 54-56 · Ernest Germain [Ernest Mandel] (signed "Albert"). Read from the scan and corrected against the page image. Reproduced with the permission of Pathfinder Press.
French text: Lettre du camarade Albert (E. Mandel) à la tendance Bleibtreu-Lambert.

Comrades:

Having been refused the right by your leaders to speak to you, I am writing you my opinion on some of the important question which you have been led to debate.

First of all, there is the question of your declaration on the question of the organizational agreement arrived at at the last Plenum of the IEC which is still pending. You must make a decision rapidly on this question. The IS will see whether it then has the need of sending the Organizational Resolution on the French Question to the sections alone or accompanied by the declaration of the minority, or accompanied by your first declaration. The latter will not fail to arouse a vehement reaction from the members of the IEC. In effect, it puts the decision taken by the IEC and the spirit in which that decision was taken in an absolutely false light. I do not think that it is in the interests of the French section to see a polemic started against it on the part of most of the members of the IEC which a declaration of the type of your first draft would inevitably provoke. No one asks you to remain silent on your opinions of the IEC agreement or to repudiate any of your political ideas. Say so briefly and simply, but without any useless and misplaced polemics on this occasion. If not, you will obtain not only from the IS but from myself as well, I am sure as well as from other members of the IEC a response which such a polemic would deserve.

Then there is the question of your attitude toward the draft of the Political Resolution presented by Comrade Frank, a draft which is clarified by the resolutions of Comrades Michele Mestre (on trade union work) and by Privas (on entrist work). Even in the opinion of one of your representatives on the Political Bureau, Comrade Garrive, these documents represent the elaboration and the coherent application of the line of the 10th Plenum — called "Entrism Sui Generis" (of its own type). We are naturally aware that that you are in disagreement with this line, and consequently in disagreement with its application. However, the essential function of the 8th Congress of the party is not to listen to the expression of agreement or disagreement with this line but to apply the line. That is the way democratic centralism is applied on an international scale. After your national congress, the function of district meetings and unit meetings is not to discuss how well-founded are the decisions of your congress, but to discuss their application. After an international congress, the national conventions do not discuss in the first place how well-founded is its line, but rather its application.

In any case, your representatives at the 10th Plenum have taken the solemn engagement, by the resolution of agreement which they have accepted, to apply the line of the 10th Plenum. You know this very well, just as you know that there is no other way for you to be disciplined in the International after the party congress than to apply this line.

[p. 55]

Consequently what is involved for you is to decide now what place the 8th Congress of the PCI will occupy on the road of the application of the line of the 10th Plenum, which means an important turn for the French section.

Either you will begin now to fight at the Congress "the coherent application of the line of the 10th Plenum" and thus, whether you wish or not, the whole of its line. In this case, the time remaining before the Congress of the party will in large part be devoted to a polemic which will not advance the party in its understanding of this line of "entrism sui generis," which will not make the party more capable of applying this line, which will increase its confusion, which will lower its cohesion, which will make the application of this line more dangerous in your opinion. You will thus not delay by a single day the application of this line, of which the great majority of the leadership of the International is convinced represents the only road to salvation for the party. You will only succeed in creating all the conditions under which the application of the line will occur with the maximum of havoc to the party. Is this really your aim? I still persist in not wanting to believe it.

Or on the other hand you can make known your different point of view from that of the minority on a certain number of questions of analysis of the situation, of political and social or economic evaluations, as well as on a certain number of proposals of concrete application of the line of the 10th Plenum made by the documents of the minority in this or that field of party activity, without placing in question the whole of the application of the orientation of the 10th Plenum, which, in the opinion of the great majority of the International leadership, is also the application of the line of the World Congress for France.

In the first case, there will be no real discussion, but only a futile polemic which will convince no one. This polemic will be all the more futile in that it will be carried on, I hope, on the other hand with the conviction that the line of orientation which you counterpose to the line contained in the documents of the minority, will not in any case be applied after the 8th Congress of the party, which, to remain disciplined in the International, will have to apply the orientation of the 10th Plenum in a coherent way. This would be an academic exercise unworthy of a revolutionary party, which would moreover cause enormous injury to the party by obliging it to effectuate a turn without cohesion or effective preparation. This would mean at the same time that it would be impossible for you to continue your role as leaders of the party after the Congress, whatever the results of the Congress. It would in effect be absurd for you to pretend to apply an orientation that you have violently fought on the very eve of its application and for which you have created an atmosphere of incomprehension or even of hostility within the party.

In the second case, there would be a really constructive discussion on each question you would raise, with the possibility of effective modification of the present documents, not only as to their letter but especially as to the orientation which will flow from that after the 8th Congress. There would then be the possibility of making a common effort within the party to better prepare to effectuate its difficult task. There would be the certainty that you would continue to play your role as leaders and that the organizational crisis which has raged in the party for more than a year would gradually disappear.

The first road which is not really to the interests of the party is the road that you will inevitably take if you adopt a "counter-document" to the documents presented by the comrades of the minority, which represent "the coherent application of the line of the 10th Plenum," even in the opinion of one of your leaders.

The second road, which represents the interests of the party, is the road you will take if you elaborate amendments, if need be numerous amendments, to the documents of the minority.

Once again, no one asks you to abandon your ideas. You are asked only to act as responsible leaders, recognizing in practice democratic centralism on the international scale: before International Congresses, discussions within the sections are centered around the determination of line; after International Congresses, the leaderships of all the sections have to make an effort to apply the adopted line in a coherent way whether they are in agreement with the line or not.

Whatever the decisions of the 8th Congress of the party, the line to be applied after the Congress will be that of "entrism sui generis": the division of the party into three sectors, one sector immediately realizing the entry, a second modifying its activity to be able to activate the entrist turn within the near future, a third continuing independent work. This regroupment of the party requires the revision of all sectors of activity, which is set forth by the documents of the minority. At the same time, it guarantees the continuation of independent work, with La Verite and other organs, with its trade union activity and its own youth work, with its recruitment and the satisfying of all its inherent needs. To discuss anything else from now to the Congress is in fact to have a Congress for nothing, to demoralize and disintegrate the party. Do not take decisions which will put such responsibilities upon you.

In discussing the agreement which took place at the 10th Plenum with your leaders, I have not left with them the slightest doubt that above all this agreement means the application of the line of the 10th Plenum, and the preparation of the party through an ample and constructive discussion for the best application of this line. At the time your leaders gave the impression of having understood that fundamentally and of not having any illusion about the possibility of elaborating "an intermediary line" of compromise between yours, as a minority in the International, and ours, that of the overwhelming majority of the International. They repeated that the only thing they desired from the agreement were organizational guarantees of such a discussion, as well as guarantees as to the existing regime within the party from the point of view of democratic centralism. However unjustified were such fears and suspicions which hide behind such demands for "guarantees," I never hesitated to give them sincerely. What has happened in the party since the conclusion of the agreement should confirm to you the complete loyalty and sincerity with which they have been applied on my part. It is not I who have fled political discussion. It is not I who have proposed or encouraged the slightest organizational measure tending to limit what is in fact the exercise of the daily leadership of the party by your tendency. Remove all unreasonable fears on this score from your mind. Our desire is to be able to collaborate with you in the leadership of the party. That this collaboration should base itself on the line of the 10th Plenum. It is not "capitulation" which is demanded of you, but the accomplishment of a duty which every Communist should consider it an honor to carry out.

[p. 56]

With fraternal greetings,

Albert

Something wrong on this page?