Meeting on June 3, 1952, the national conference of cadres of the majority tendency has examined the situation in the party and its relations with the International Secretariat.
Having heard the report of Comrade Albert, characterized by the reporter himself as an ultimatum and which signifies the prohibition of all political expression of the majority of the party in the discussion for the Eighth Congress and in the Congress itself, the conference has to draw the conclusion that this is a violation of the agreements arrived at the Tenth Plenum.
These agreements were based on the following points:
1. The majority accepted the constitution of the Political Bureau controlled by the minority, by virtue of the deciding vote accorded to the member of the IS designated by the IEC for a period covering the preparation of the Congress and for three months thereafter.
2. The IEC decided on the holding of a democratic congress which would guarantee the democratic expression of tendencies, of the submission of documents to a vote of the congress before treating of the problems defined in the guiding-document, total freedom of expression on all questions being moreover recognized for all members of the party, including members of the Political Bureau.
In order to remain in the International the majority accepted a minority leadership on the one condition that the Eighth Congress be democratically prepared.
To claim that the utilization of this right recognized by the IEC shows a lack of discipline, on the pretext that the minority expresses "the line of the IEC" and that the majority has disagreements with it, and to threaten the majority with sanctions for not having rallied purely and simply to the resolutions of the minority is to directly violate the agreement and to unmask a crude ruse perpetrated on the IEC and to the French Section.
Thus are explained the reasons because of which obstacles were created, first by ruse for several months, then by veto, to the publication of the declaration of the majority on the meaning of its acceptance of the agreement of the Tenth Plenum.
In his letter of May 23, and more clearly in his intervention of that day, and more clearly in his speech of that day, Comrade Albert eliminates all possibility of tendency expression in the discussion for the congress; according to him, the presentation of any kind of a political document by the majority is declared prescribed. The only out that he offers for the majority, is to draft in common with the minority a technical document of application and to withdraw all political documents under penalty of sanctions and its declarations on the agreements of the 10th Plenum.
The duplicity of such a proposal appears clearly in the refusal of Comrade Albert and the minority to accept the motion and a joint vote on the document on the practical problems of entrism, which is acceptable insofar as it is based completely in the sphere of under ground activity. On such a basis, the numerical proportion between the en-trist sector and the independent sector appeared as a secondary problem on which an agreement was possible.
The rejection of this possibility by Comrade Albert and the minority clearly demonstrates that their aim is not the realization of some kind of strategy by the party as a whole, but the political hara-kiri of the majority and its destruction.
This organizational attitude confirms our worst premonitions on the Political Resolution of the minority, in the form of a hypocritical exegesis of the documents of the 10th Plenum, which affirmed: "The independent sector maintains all present essential activities in the factories, the trade unions, the youth, and continues to recruit, from among the best elements within the ranks of the Stalinist movement on the part of our militants who carry on en-trist work." They now take the obverse of this position and piece by piece destroy all the necessary activities for the existence of the independent organization.
It confirms the uneasiness caused among all members of the party by the publication in Quatrieme Internationale of the report of the 10th Plenum, an act whose significance has been correctly defined by the resolution presented by the majority members of the Political Bureau.
It clarifies the meaning of the opposition of the minority leaders to all criticism of the policy of the CP manifested among other things at the time of the publication of an article in La Verite on the Billoux report, an article which was reproached for not being content with emphasizing only the positive aspects of the turn, when the report of the 10th Plenum declared: "Our organs have the duty to fully develop our entire policy, in all its themes, to make a clear, unequivocal, concrete criticism of Stalinist policy, etc. . . . without any limitations other than that of the language and the form which should be thought out in a manner to find a growing echo from the Stalinist workers and militants."
[p. 58]
* * *
It appears evident today that the political differences have deepened, leading to incompatibility of the reciprocal paralysis of the tendencies.
Such a situation cannot be perpetuated without serious harm to the existence of the party and for its activities either in the entrist sector or in the independent sector.
In recent months, the struggle of the tendencies has only accentuated, causing a growing paralysis of the party. This could not be otherwise because of the fact that the minority, after the 10th Plenum and although it had obtained control of the Political Bureau, organized itself as a faction with a weekly meeting of all its members in a permanent headquarters. This unjustifiable factional activity has had only negative expressions such as the organized abstention of participation in the campaign for the circulation and the defense of La Verite.
In all spheres the minority had adopted a factional attitude of undermining the independent sector.
It has placed the party in the worst situation. In the sphere of organization and of activity as well as on the political plane, on the very problem of the existence of the party, such an incompatibility has been manifested between the tendencies as to neutralize and nullify the capacity of the French section for action.
Because of this fact, to attempt to maintain the status quo would be to court disaster. It is necessary to get out of it, to create the condition of genuine cooperation preserving the achievements of Trotskyism in France.
This in no case can be achieved by means of ultimatism, threats, sanctions, suspensions or expulsions.
The only road open, consistent with the need of combining the two forms of work, entrist and independent, is the adoption of a solution comparable to the one which exists in Austria; the recognition by the IEC of two organizations of the Fourth International in France.
In this way only the organizational and human conquests of Trotskyism can be safeguarded in France. In this very way only can the correctness of this or that orientation be verified in experience. If it has confidence in its orientation, the IS should make itself the defender of such a solution, for the confirmation of its views through experience alone can eradicate all suspicions.
The recognition of the independent organization provides guarantees of discipline and expression on public political actions of the independent organization, which no one can deny, is based entirely on the programmatic foundations of Trotskyism.
* * *
The national conference of the majority unanimously rejects the ultimatum of Comrade Albert and addresses itself to the IEC to request it to adopt the position which will permit a positive settlement of an impasse which can no longer continue.
In places confidence in the IEC to reject any ultimatistic and destructive positions.
It warns unequivocally that any measure of suspension, of sanctions, even veiled or deferred, against representatives of the tendency in the leadership, that any veto of a democratic discussion for the Congress will be considered as a splitting measure, of exclusion and of destruction of the PCI.
Such a measure will automatically be a splitting measure for which the International leadership will bear full responsibility.
The proletarian majority of the party is certain that the IEC will act with discernment, with a will to preserve the unity of the International and all its achievements, and will adopt the proposal for the recognition of two organizations in France.
(Adopted unanimously)