May 3, 1952
(4 for —Frank, Privas, Albert, M. Mestre; 3 against — Bleibtreu, Gernier, Lambert)
In rejecting the document submitted as a draft of a Political Resolution by Comrades Bleibtreu, Lambert, Renard and Garrive, the Political Bureau is obliged to state the following to the entire party:
In form as in essence this document is a flagrant violation of the agreement concluded at the 10th Plenum by the representatives of the majority of the party, and of the guide-text adopted by them at the Political Bureau at the time of the opening of the preparatory discussion for the 8th Plenum of the party.
The line of the 10th Plenum, is that of entrism sui generis, the independent party adapting its evolution and its tasks to the primary needs of the entrist sector which should be progressively extended. The draft of the Political Resolution, which has been rejected, defines as the line the refusal of entrism, and substitutes for it a limited "fraction work" only for comrades who are not rooted in the working class.
Far from trying to apply the line of the 10th Plenum in France, to which however the comrades of the majority of the party on several occasions and in a solemn way committed themselves, their document fights this line fundamentally. It does so moreover in a veiled and dissembling way without daring to clearly counterpose a different orientation to it, feigning to ignore the decisions taken at the 10th Plenum and thus sowing the worst confusion in the party. The maneuverist character of the proposals of the majority of the party appear more clearly in their offer to adopt — with amendments — the document on entrism presented by Comrade Privas, while their draft of the Political Resolution implicitly and explicitly rejects the orientation put forward by Comrade Privas. That is why the majority of the Political Bureau has decided to incorporate this document in the Political Resolution adopted at the Political Bureau meeting of March 20, and to present both documents which form a single whole before the Congress of the party.
The party is placed before the need of an important and difficult turn in all spheres of its activity. This turn, made necessary by changing events in the objective situation has in any case been decided by the responsible organisms of the International. The draft of the Political Resolution presented by the majority of the 7th Congress of the party constitutes both a refusal to execute a turn, an attempt to do everything to prevent this turn from being effectuated rapidly, freely and with enthusiasm by the party, and an inability to counterpose an alternative to the path of party-building decided upon by the International leadership. The new Political Bureau cannot otherwise characterize such a document except as an undertaking of demoralization, division and disintegration of the party. The document presented by Comrades Bleibtreu, Lambert, Renard and Garrive was elaborated outside of the Political Bureau and blocking all activity of the political committee for four weeks, without any discussion with Comrade Albert, who is responsible for the French section to the IEC, all the above mentioned comrades agreeing that he is quite capable of correctly interpreting the line of the Tenth Plenum. This document is the fruit of their refusal of correctly interpreting the line of the Tenth Plenum. This document is the fruit of their refusal for such a preliminary discussion which has been repeated in spite of repeated efforts by Comrade Albert in that direction. Under these conditions the very manner in which the document has been drawn up cannot otherwise be characterized by the Political Bureau than as a premeditated act of hostility to the line of the International, which is incompatible with commitments made at the Tenth Plenum. This document has no other aim than to perpetuate the crisis and the paralysis of the party- At the same time it confirms the intention of the leaders of the majority tendency to continue an uninterrupted and violent factional struggle for the whole period of application of the line decided upon by the International, a period during which, according to the statutes of the International such a struggle should be removed completely to the background. On the part of the responsible leaders of the majority tendency in the party this represents a real rupture with the elementary organizational principles of Bolshevism. The Political Bureau consequently will be obliged to address itself to the next IEC meeting and to demand of it that for a long period the comrades responsible for such actions which are prejudicial to the party be considered disqualified as a tendency to exercise any post of leadership in the party.
The majority of the Political Bureau, designated by the Tenth Plenum, has sedulously abstained from manifesting itself as such in any way whatever despite the open and repeated actions of hostility toward the International on the part of representatives of the Political Bureau of the majority of the party (a campaign against the publication of the report on the Tenth Plenum in Quatrieme Internationale, the draft of the political resolution now presented, the maintenance of the declaration on the agreement of the Tenth Plenum which distorts the meaning of this agreement, etc. . . .). It is only after these acts have accumulated that it is now firmly decided to act collectively to execute the mandate which it has received from the Tenth Plenum: to defend the International and its political orientation in the French section.
[p. 57]
The draft of the political resolution rejected by the Political Bureau runs the risk of diverting the discussion before the Eighth Congress and at the Congress itself in the meanderings of an academic futile polemic which is without any practical interest to the party. After the congress of the party it is the whole of the party which will have to apply, and to apply immediately, the line of the Tenth Plenum to remain disciplined to the International, to utilize possibilities which are open now more than ever in France. The Political Bureau calls upon the entire party to ignore the sterile polemic begun by the representatives of the majority and to pose for itself one single aim in the discussion before the congress: how to arm the party to the maximum for the most effective, the most fruitful possible application of the line already decided upon. Only this line permits the integration of Trotskyism in the revolutionary struggles which are coming. Only this line permits the building of a genuine revolutionary leadership. For all districts and all units of the party there is only one slogan from now to the congress: Study and work to apply the line of the Tenth Plenum.
The Political Bureau decides that the present declaration, together with Comrade Albert's letter to the majority tendency on April 22, be made known immediately to the entire party. It demands of the IS to also make them known to all members of the IEC.