Fourth International Documents

Conferences, congresses and resolutions, in English

From the splits to reunification 1952-1963 › The Fifth World Congress and after (1957–1960)

Documents: Appeal of the International Secretariat Distributed at the Youth Congress in Vienna — Back to Lenin!

Fourth International No. 7, Autumn 1959 · The Fifth World Congress and after (1957–1960) · 2,400 words

France USSR and Russia Algeria and the Maghreb Youth and students Socialist democracy and workers' councils Colonial revolution and national liberation

Published English text: by International Secretariat of the Fourth International, transcribed from the scan and corrected against the page image (the page on Fourth International Publications is mis-split).
French text: Un appel de la IVe Internationale au Festival de la Jeunesse à Vienne (« Retour à Lénine ! »).

Don't listen to imperialist propaganda, in which to its dishonor, the leadership of the Socialist Party and the Socialist Youth also participate. Listen to us, who speak as communists to communists. Listen to the voice of revolutionary Marxism!

Dear friends and comrades,

In the name of revolutionary Marxists everywhere, who have unflinchingly upheld the banner of Leninism, we greet the progressive and working-class youth of all countries, assembled in Vienna for the Youth Festival.

We greet the young workers, peasants, and students of the Soviet Union, of New China, of the “people’s democracies” of Eastern Europe and Asia, who are building a new and better society. Whatever criticism we have of the political regime in these countries; whatever may be the distortions and deviations from the true path of Marxism-Leninism of which the bureaucratic leaders of these countries are guilty, we shall never underestimate the gigantic importance of the economic and social progress achieved thanks to the nationalization of the means of production, the suppression of capitalism, the building of a planned economy.

This progress we hail enthusiastically. We call upon the youth and the workers of all countries to defend it with all their strength against attacks and attempts at subversion on behalf of reactionary imperialism,

All Help to the Heroic Colonial Revolution!

We greet the young workers, peasants, and students of the colonial and semi-colonial countries, of Asia, the Arab world, Negro Africa, and Latin America. We greet the heroic fighters of the unconquerable struggle for freedom and independence of all oppressed peoples, who are writing a unique and glorious page in the history of human emancipation.

We call upon the youth and the workers of all countries to give their utmost help to the colonial revolution, and above all to the Algerian revolution, upon which the whole

The imperialists hide behind the mask of “freedom.” But their reign is marked by countless crimes against the freedom and dignity of all peoples, by savage repression against the peoples of Korea, Vietnam, Malaya, Kenya, South Africa, the Cameroons, Guatemala, and above all their inhuman war against the Algerian people in which more than half a million people have already been slaughtered in the last four years.

Have no confidence in the crusaders for “free enterprise” and their various self-titled “democratic” lackeys! Capitalism is a decaying reactionary system; it is able to ensure the workers of some privileged imperialist countries a relatively high standard of living only at the expense of terrible exploitaion of hundreds of millions of colonial slaves, whose incomes are less than 10% of the average income of the Western countries.

Whatever wrongs must be righted in the USSR and in the people’s democracies, must be righted by the toilers of these countries themselves, never by the stooges of American imperialism! power of French imperialism and its NATO allies is brought to bear. Dockers, railroad-workers, pilots, refuse to load and transport arms for the French colonial army! Workers of the capitalist countries, express your protest against the cruelties and tortures of French imperialism in huge meetings, demonstrations, and solidarity strikes! Workers of the Soviet Union and the other workers’ states, call upon your governments to give much greater help, money, and especially arms to the heroic Algerian people, and to recognize its government.

The organization of a world-wide movement of political support and practical help for the colonial revolution is today the utmost duty of the international labor movement. It is only through such a huge movement of class solidarity that the oppressed toilers of the colonial and semi-colonial countries will learn not to have confidence in their own national bourgeois exploiters, to build their own revolutionary parties of workers and poor peasants.

Progressive and Communist Militants of Underdeveloped Countries!

The examples of Russia, Jugoslavia, China, and Vietnam completely confirm the lessons of Trotsky’s theory of the permanent revolution. The revolution in backward colonial ‘or semi-colonial countries will triumph and open a definite road to national rebirth and growth only if it is led by a revolutionary working-class party and arrives al the conquest of power by the toiling masses.

All attempts to limit the revolution to a stage of “democratic revolution,” of collaboration with the “national bourgeoisie,” to which in fact the leadership of the revolution is delivered, can lead only to stagnation and defeat. The recent tragic examples of Guatemala, Iran, Egyot, Indonesia, and Argentina, provide a lesson which must not be forgotten. In all these countries, Communist Parties called upon the people to support bourgeois democratic “progressive” forces. Today, Frondizi, for whom the Argentine CP called the workers to vote, has unmasked himself as a stooge of imperialism. Nasser has organized a violent repression of the communist and working-class movement. Sukarno will do so tomorrow.

Communists and progressives should support each step forward of national bourgeois leaders against imperialism in underdeveloped countries. But at the same time they should constantly warn the toiling masses of their countries, that the final victory over imperialism is impossible without a general uprising of the masses, without their organization in democratic committees, the overthrow of the old state machine, and the leadership of the masses by a revolutionary, communist party.

Put the Overthrow of Capitalism on the Agenda in the West!

We greet the young workers, peasants, and students who have come to Vienna from the industrialized capitalist countries of the West. They come from countries where the labor movement, in contrast to the magnificent upsurge of the colonial revolution, is witnessing serious retreats. In France, the coming to power of de Gaulle is a great defeat for the working class; it creates for the first time since 1945 a threat of fascism in Western Europe.

In most of the other Western countries, the Communist Parties are weaker than ever since the Second World War, sometimes even weaker than during the ’20s. Notwithstanding the tremendous crisis in the ’30s and during and after the Second World War, capitalists everywhere in the West have succeeded in temporarily restabilizing their economy and their state.

This is not at all the “fatal” result of the “cold war,” “American intervention,’ and the , ‘“anti-communist campaign.” It is. the result of fatally wrong policies of the Communist -Parties. At the end of the war, these parties were everywhere in rapid growth. The masses, disgusted by capitalism and disappointed by Social-Democratic reformism,. wanted new and radical changes. In France, Italy, and Greece, power was within reach of the labor movement. —.

At that time, however, the leaders of the Communist Parties, aided and abetted. by Stalin and the leaders of the. Soviet Union, completely failed to live up to their historic. task of destroying capitalism (with the exception of the leadership of the Jugoslav Communist Party, which, against Stalin’s orders, established a workers’ state in its country). They participated in bourgeois coalition governments. They sang the praise of the “new” capitalist democracy. They condemned strikes as “weapons of the trusts.” They did everything in their power to reconstruct the capitalist economy and the capitalist state. When the combativity of the working class was exhausted, and the masses deeply. disappointed, the bourgeoisie broke this coalition. It could isolate the Communist Parties because they had first of all betrayed the revolutionary socialist aspirations of the workers.

In no other country is this so clear as it is in France. The French CP participated actively in the creation of the de Gaulle cult. It spread scandalous chauvinist propaganda — vying with the Gaullists in the defense of the “greatness of France.” It was opposed to a destruction of the so-called “Union Frangaise,” that peoples’ prison! Its ministers actively participated in the savage repression of the uprising of the Algerian people in May 1945. Its deputies voted the military credits for the war against the Vietnamese people at the end of 1946. As late as January 1958, a few months before de Gaulle’s coming to power, it claimed that the main task of the French workers was not the fight for Algerian independence but... the fight for French (sic) independence, against the building of American rocket bases on French territory!

This criminally doomed policy has powerfully assisted the French bourgeoisie in creating a chauvinist current inside the working class. It has paralyzed and sabotaged effective working-class action against the Algerian war, in the spirit of the campaign against the Morocco war organized by a much weaker French Communist Party in 1925. It has paved the way for the Gaullist dictatorship. It. continues to disarm the French workers by creating the stupid parliamentary illusion that this dictatorship could be overthrown through “election victories.”

Communist and Progressive Workers of Western Europe!

It is necessary to come back to Lenin’s programme of uncompromising struggle against capitalism, its state and its economy. The working class will score its victories over Western capitalism not as a result of what happens elsewhere in the world, but only as a result of its own anti-capitalist struggle. It is necessary to work out in each country a concrete programme of transitional demands which, starting from the immediate concerns of the masses, mobilize them in an anti-capitalist struggle. It is necessary, in other words, to put the overthrow of capitalism on the agenda, instead of pushing it back to the distant future of a “great capitalist crisis” or of “the Soviet Union overtaking America’s production and per capita consumption.”

For a Return to Soviet Democracy! Young Communists of the Workers' States!

The slogan “back to Lenin” applies first of all to your own countries. The present leadership of the CPSU pays lip-service to the same slogan. But its practice is very far from this promise. os

Undoubtedly many things have changed for the better since Stalin’s death. The worst excesses of police dictatorship, the. concentration camps, the inhuman labor laws, have been suppressed. But the Soviet Union is still far from the soviet democracy which it experienced under Lenin and Trotsky.

“Back to Lenin” — this means above all back to truth. You may deceive and lie to the class enemy in the class struggle, Lenin taught; you may never lie to your own party and your own class. But Khrushchev has not told you the truth about the terrible years of Stalinist dictatorship — he has given you only part of the picture. He has passed over the role which he himself, with all the present leaders of the CPSU, played as accomplices to Stalin's cruel crimes against the people, the working class, and the communists of the Soviet Union and all countries — these crimes which in Autumn 1941 brought the Soviet state within an inch of its downfall. He has not given you a serious Marxist evaluation and explanation of these crimes. “The personality cult” is a completely non-Marxist formula; it replaces the struggle of social forces by individual psychology as a fundamental explanation of a whole historical period.

In reality, Stalin’s reign and crimes are not to be explained by his personality, but by the social conflict between the ruling bureaucracy and the masses of the workers. The purpose of these crimes was to defend against the toiling masses the growing inequality, the huge privileges of the bureaucracy, its usurpation of all political power, the “one-man-rule” in the factories.

Today, although Khrushchev has been forced to make many concessions to the workers, this rule of the bureaucracy remains basically unchanged. Khrushchev even defends it with guns and tanks, as he did against the Hungarian workers’ revolution. There are no workers’ soviets in the factories who have the right to decide on the plan, the right to dismiss the managers. There are no workers soviets in the cities and the republics who, in free and democratic discussion, map out the general policy of the state. There is no freedom of tendencies and of discussion in the Communist Party as in the time of Lenin and Trotsky, no freedom to draft different resolutions and theses and fight for them within the party, before congresses.

“Back to Lenin” means, for the Soviet Union, back to soviet democracy, ie, full democratic rights and freedom for the toiling people. Soviet democracy today, when the capitalist class has physically disappeared from the Soviet Union, when the destruction of capitalism is definitively achieved, as Khrushchev himself admitted at the XXIst Party Congress, means not only the freedom for ideological tendencies inside the Communist Parties, but also the freedom for the organization of all Soviet parties based upon the defense of the nationalized property and opposed to world capitalism.

In order to discover for yourself the road back to Lenin, back to truth, back to soviet democracy, to self-government of the working people — you have to study the literature of the Old Bolsheviks murdered by Stalin, the faithful comrades-in-arms of Lenin who together with him engineered the victory of the October Revolution, and built the Soviet State and the Communist International.

Fight for free access to all libraries and archives! Study the works of Bukharin, Zinoviev, Kamenev, Rakovsky, Piatakov, Preobashensky, Radek, and the closest collaborator of Lenin during and after the October Revolution, the leader of the October insurrection and creator of the Red Army, Lev Davidovitch Trotsky. Denounce the new falsifications which, contrary to the solemn promises made at the XXth Party Congress, abound in the newly edited History of the CPSU, and which you can discover easily by studying the historical documents of the years 1917- 1927. Ask for a full rehabilation of all the victims of the infamous Yechovtchina, the victims of the infamous Moscow Trials, where the leaders of Lenin’s Central Committee were forced by torture to besmirch their own imperishable memory. Fight in your universities, factories, youth and party organizations, and trade unions, for an increase of equality and democracy! Organize yourselves!

Build study circles to compare the programs of the various opposition tendencies within the CPSU after 1923 with the reality of Stalin’s crimes denounced by Khrushchev, with the reality of the Soviet Union today. Familiarize yourself with the writings and works of Trotsky and the world Trotskyist movement which for 30 years has kept the stainless banner of Leninism flying, despite inhuman persecution by fascism, capitalist reaction, and Stalinism. By such objective study, we are sure, you will end by finding the road toward the Leninism of today, which lives and struggles through the Fourth International!

THE INTERNATIONAL SECRETARIAT OF THE FOURTH INTERNATIONAL

Something wrong on this page?